Stories for Growing
Cover of The Carrot SeedAges 3 to 6
PersistenceConfidence

The Carrot Seed

Ruth Krauss, illustrated by Crockett Johnson

Ages 3 to 6
About this age guidance

Kirkus (1945 review): 3 to 6; Kirkfield blog: 2 and up

The age tag follows Kirkus review. Other sources may suggest different ages. This is audience guidance, not an independent reading level.

A librarian ranks it number 100 in a School Library Journal picture book poll and quotes a summary of a boy who keeps watering his seed while everyone says it won’t come up.

A small boy plants a carrot seed. His mother and others around him keep saying it won’t come up, but he waters and tends it every day. A very big carrot comes up in the end.

Good forGiving up when things get hardLow confidence

Recommended by A Fuse #8 Production (School Library Journal)

Find at Bookshop.org Find on Amazon

Choose your preferred shop and check the edition there.

What children see in the story

The boy waters and tends his seed every day while everyone says it will not come up, and the carrot finally grows. He trusts that his seed will grow when everyone else doubts it, and a huge carrot proves him right.

Why it’s on these shelves

Persistence
A little boy plants a carrot seed. His mother and others keep saying it won’t come up, but he waters and tends it every day until a huge carrot grows.
Confidence
The boy’s mother and everyone around him say the seed won’t come up. He pays them no mind and keeps tending it, and the biggest carrot in many counties proves him right.

Why pick it up?

The carrot grows, bigger than anyone expected.

A note for parents

The text is about 101 words. Kirkus’s 1945 review is a few sentences, so the plot beats rest on a librarian’s quote of a children’s-literature scholar’s summary plus a writer’s blog post. The librarian page says readers see faith, persistence or ignoring naysayers in it. Persistence and confidence are the readings supported by moments about daily care and doubt. Hardcover chosen because it carries the 1945 text and art; Amazon shows the same rating pool for the anniversary paperback.

Where this recommendation comes from

A Fuse #8 Production (School Library Journal)

A librarian ranks it number 100 in a School Library Journal picture book poll and quotes a summary of a boy who keeps watering his seed while everyone says it won’t come up.

Read Betsy Bird’s recommendation
Sources and review status

We have checked source descriptions and drafted the value mapping. We have not personally reviewed the full book. The value labels, situation assignments, and parent notes remain provisional.

Publisher or literacy resource · Original recommendation

Our explanation of the value fit is separate from the original reviewer’s judgment. Their inclusion here does not imply an endorsement of Stories for Growing.

Another good example

Browse more values